An excellent white elephant gift succeeds on multiple levels—a practical item is always welcome, but a unique gift that can raise a laugh or, better yet, inspire a steal or a swap, is always in demand. While shopping for the loved ones on your list can be more straightforward, securing the right white elephant gift takes creativity, ingenuity, and a sense of humor. Lucky for you, however, we’ve taken some of the guesswork out of finding a cheeky (and steal-worthy) gift for your next holiday party—and the best part? They all clock in at $25 or less. Read on for TIME’s best white elephant gifts of 2023—and check out last year’s list for even more ideas.

Read more: 18 Luxurious Gifts Worth the Splurge

Sriracha hot chocolate mix

Heat things up this winter with a piquant twist on a classic holiday drink. The iconic tangy and sweet spice of sriracha adds a kick to hot chocolate with this unique mix.

Buy now: $4.95 at McSteven’s; $14.99 at Amazon

A DIY sushi candy making kit

Give sushi a sweet makeover with this playful candy making kit. Complete with all the ingredients and a mold tray, you can cr…

Read More